GOLD 1251.49 $/ozChange: 5.85
PLATINUM 1555.00 $/ozChange: 23.00
R/$ exchange 7.25Change: 0.05
R/€ exchange 9.29Change: 0.05
 
We have detected that the browser you are using is no longer supported. As a result, some content may not display correctly.
We suggest that you upgrade to the latest version of any of the following browsers:
         
close notification
powered by
Advanced Search
 
 
 
Home
 
Most Popular Articles
 
 
HEAVY MINERALS
Xolobeni appeal hearings cancelled
1 COMMENTS  |  
ADD A COMMENT PRINT
 
 
10th February 2010
TEXT SIZE
Text Smaller Disabled Text Bigger
 

The hearings involving interested parties appealing a decision to grant Transworld Energy Minerals (TEM) a licence to mine heavy minerals from the dunes near Xolobeni on the Wild Coast, scheduled to take place this week, were cancelled.

The committee of four people, which was appointed by the Mining and Minerals Board to oversee the presentations from all parties involved, could not proceed because it had not received the necessary documentation from the Department of Mineral Resources (DMR).

Committee chairperson Pathekile Holomisa told Mining Weekly Online that it had now received the documentation, which it would go through, and would decide in March whether or not hearings into the matter in fact needed to take place.

"Ultimately, our piece would be to advise the Minister, either to proceed with granting the license, or cancel or withdraw it, but that depends on our understanding of the issue. And we shall also decide whether there is a need to invite more oral presentations or not," he explained.

Grahamstown-based Legal Resources Centre (LRC) representative Sarah Sephton said that the cancellation of the hearings was "completely unsatisfactory', as the LRC had made the effort to submit its volumes of documentation on time to the DMR.

She added that the LRC, as well as representatives from the mining company TEM, and the company's black economic-empowerment partner, Xolco, travelled to the KwaZulu-Natal DMR offices for the scheduled hearings "at great cost", only to be told that hearings were not going to take place.

The LRC represented the Amadiba Crisis Committee (ACC), which was appealing the mining right, which the former Minerals and Energy Minister, Buyelwa Sonjica, granted in August 2008.

The LRC stated that one of the grounds for the appeal was that the mining right was granted to the Australia-based mining junior without sufficient and reasonable consultation with the Xolobeni community as an interested and affected party.

On September 28, 2009, the LRC submitted two expert reports to the Minister in support of the appeal to set aside the mining right. One of the reports provided that the heavy minerals mining operations planned by TEM had been discontinued in other jurisdictions, such as Australia and New Zealand.

Resolution on whether or not the licence to mine for titanium-bearing minerals would, in fact, be granted was expected by June 2009, however, little clarity on the matter had emerged.

 

Edited by: Mariaan Webb
 
 
 
 
 
Hide Comments  
 
Readers Comments
 
image image
A futher reason ciited by the chairman's excuse for postponing/cancelling the hearings needs to be put on record. The fact is MRC/TEM arrived without their lawyers, Xolco arrived with a junior attorney while the Amadiba Crisis Committee arrived with Adv Gilbert Marcus SC, Adv Isabel Goodman and attorney Sarah Septhon. Peashooters going up against cannons. No self respecting advisory committee can arrive at a fair recommendation without a reasoble balance of representation. Moreover in the "court of public opinion" the mining venture was also facing a massacre. DMR insisted that the hearing was 'closed to the media', but two journalists arrived at the venue, apparently having been told by Chairman Holomisa that as far as he was concerned they should be there. The proceedings started 45 minutes late while the comittee and DMR officials caucused. The only way the mining proposal can possibly prevail is by a war of attrition, sapping the resources of Civil Society. However these delays and postponments are serving to strenghten civil society, and give those who once supported the mining proposal reason to change their mind. Former directors of Xolco now have some very interesting stories to tell as to why they resigned. When Mr Holomisa and the committee watch the DVD recordings of these, there is only one recommendation they can make. Cancel the licence and institute criminal proceedings against the mining company and Xolco lawyers for fraud.
image image 
image
John Clarke on 13th February 2010
 
A view from the proposed heavy minerals mining site at Xolobeni.
 
Picture by: Christy van der Merwe
A view from the proposed heavy minerals mining site at Xolobeni.