GOLD 1251.41 $/ozChange: 5.77
PLATINUM 1555.00 $/ozChange: 23.00
R/$ exchange 7.25Change: 0.05
R/€ exchange 9.29Change: 0.05
 
We have detected that the browser you are using is no longer supported. As a result, some content may not display correctly.
We suggest that you upgrade to the latest version of any of the following browsers:
         
close notification
powered by
Advanced Search
 
 
 
Home
 
Breaking News
 
 
NEWS ANALYSIS
Beijing fuels old debate about gold's true value
2 COMMENTS  |  
ADD A COMMENT PRINT
 
 
9th July 2010
TEXT SIZE
Text Smaller Disabled Text Bigger
 

In a musing about the value of gold, the late financier and adviser to US Presidents Bernard Baruch once opined that, when something holds good for 2 000 years, "I do not believe it can be so because of prejudice or mistaken theory." He also noted that gold had "worked down from Alexander's time".

However, the value of gold is always a contested subject - a reality that became apparent again this week, when the Chinese government said that it was not going to dump the US dollar and go on a great golden shopping spree. The price of the yellow metal subsequently slipped below $1 200/oz, from over $1 265/oz just days before.

The Chinese government said in a statement: "Gold is globally recognised as a store of value and can be used for urgent payment, but there are some limits to investing in gold, and it cannot become a main channel for investing our foreign exchange reserves."

This is an obvious statement. Firstly, there's not enough gold in the world for it to become a central pillar of Beijing's investment holdings. Secondly, if China said that it was going to become a major investor in gold, the price would arguably go through the roof.

China's State Administration of Foreign Exchange (Safe) highlighted the fact that even if it doubled the 1 054 t of gold it holds, it would have a negligible effect on its portfolio. Safe holds nearly $2,5-trillion, and 2 000 t of gold would be worth about $77-billion.

There is the school of thought that if Safe were to gradually grow its gold reserves, it wouldn't have much of an effect on the gold price.

The argument goes that China is the biggest producer of gold; therefore there is no requirement to buy the yellow metal from other countries.

But the Asian powerhouse is also the world's biggest producer of coal, and that hasn't stopped it from importing large amounts of the fuel. And, while Chinese gold production may be on the up, places such as South Africa have shown massive declines.

In fact, figures from consultancy GFMS show that global supply contracted by three per cent in 2008.

According to the World Gold Council, China's demand for gold grew by 11% in the first quarter of this year to 105,2 t, notwithstanding the higher prices.

But while Safe argues gold investments don't pay dividends (though the investor has to pay storage and insurance costs), the metal has held it's value over the last 2 000 years, as Baruch said.

Not many companies are still around from Alexander's time that you can still buy shares in - can't think of any paper currencies either.

 

Edited by: Terence Creamer
 
 
Topics in this article
City Country Currency Industry Term
Person  
 
 
 
 
 
Hide Comments  
 
Readers Comments
 
image image
The US is a failed financial state. If you believe the Chinese are foolish enough to continue to use Bernanke's clown confetti as a reserve currency in the future- you are delusional. The Chinese will tell the average idiot one thing and do the opposite. From their perspective it will get the Sheeple to dump their Gold at the nearest "Cash fo Gold" or local equivalent. The value of the US dollar will decend to the level of the Weimar D-Mark. This value levels out at the heat it generates during winter when it is burned as fuel.
image image 
image
Anonymous on 9th July 2010
image image
If, as you claim, gold prices "would go through the roof" if China started buying gold, then surely there could be enough gold to replace the world's fiat currencies. It all depends on what "go through the roof" means.
image image 
image
alan white on 9th July 2010
 
 
Picture by: Bloomberg News